Incorporator The Journal of U.S. Formation
Start Free Quiz
Editorial 11 MIN READ

Hawaii in late November 2019: the $50 filing, the quarterly report, and a tax that does not behave like a sales tax

An Articles of Organization filed with the DCCA, an annual report keyed to your formation quarter, and a General Excise Tax that reaches wholesale transactions most other states exempt

The Editors
Staff, Incorporator.org
11 min read Updated
Contents 6 sections
  1. The mechanics
  2. The annual report, and the filing-quarter system Hawaii uses
  3. The General Excise Tax, which is not a sales tax
  4. Income tax, which is the highest top rate in the country
  5. Who forming in Hawaii actually makes sense for
  6. Sources

awaii LLC formation costs $50 to file Articles of Organization online and $15 a year to keep the entity current, which puts the front-end numbers near the bottom of the national table. The line item that moves the total-cost-of-ownership math is not on the Business Registration Division's fee schedule at all. It is the General Excise Tax, and it reaches places sales taxes in other states do not.

This is a guide for someone forming in Hawaii in late November 2019, written to the Business Registration Division's Hawaii Business Express portal as it actually behaves and to Haw. Rev. Stat. Chapter 428 as it actually reads.

The mechanics

You file Articles of Organization with the Business Registration Division of the Department of Commerce and Consumer Affairs, which Hawaii calls the DCCA. The governing statute is the Hawaii Uniform Limited Liability Company Act, codified at Haw. Rev. Stat. Chapter 428, which Hawaii enacted in 1996 as one of the earlier states to adopt the Uniform Law Commission's first ULLCA. The Act has been amended in the intervening two decades but has not been replaced wholesale; an LLC forming in November 2019 forms under Chapter 428 in substantially the same statutory architecture that has governed Hawaii LLCs since the late 1990s.

The Articles themselves are short. Haw. Rev. Stat. § 428-203 sets out the required content: the name of the LLC (which must include "limited liability company," "L.L.C.," or "LLC," with the "limited" permitted to abbreviate to "Ltd." and "company" to "Co."), the mailing address of the LLC's principal office, the name and street address in Hawaii of the registered agent, the name and address of each organizer, whether the LLC is manager-managed or member-managed, and in either case the name and address of each initial manager or each initial member. Hawaii is on the disclosure-forward end of the national spectrum; a member-managed LLC will list its members on the public record from day one.

The online filing fee is $50 through Hawaii Business Express, the DCCA's e-filing portal at hbe.ehawaii.gov. A paper filing runs $75 because the Division adds a $25 manual processing surcharge to submissions that arrive by mail and have to be keyed in by a clerk. The surcharge is a deliberate nudge toward the portal and at this point there is no reason to mail Articles of Organization unless your signatory is working from a context that rules out electronic signing. Hawaii Business Express returns a filed stamp within one to three business days in normal queues. There is no tiered expedite menu the way Delaware sells one; the Division runs a single $25 expedite option for reviewed filings that is usually unnecessary for a routine Articles of Organization.

You will then need an EIN, which the IRS issues on Form SS-4 Online at no charge. You will need an operating agreement, which Haw. Rev. Stat. § 428-103 recognizes as the controlling internal document and which the state does not require you to file. And you will need to decide, for federal tax purposes, whether to accept the default classification (disregarded entity for a single-member LLC, partnership for a multi-member LLC), or to file Form 8832 to elect C-corp treatment, or Form 2553 to elect S-corp treatment. Most Hawaii founders leave the default alone through the first year and revisit on the first return.

A name reservation is available for $10 and holds a name for 120 days; most founders skip it because the availability search built into Hawaii Business Express clears conflicts in under a minute. The name rules in § 428-103.5 include the usual "distinguishable on the record" test and a short list of restricted words (bank, insurance, trust, and a handful of others) that require collateral approval from the relevant Hawaii regulator before the Division will accept the Articles.

The annual report, and the filing-quarter system Hawaii uses

Hawaii's annual report is short, cheap, and tied to a schedule most mainland filers find unusual. Under Haw. Rev. Stat. § 428-210, every domestic and foreign LLC must file an annual report with the DCCA each year. The filing fee is $15 online through Hawaii Business Express. A paper filing runs $12.50 more because the same manual-processing surcharge applies; the online path is the default and the cost-minimizing choice.

The filing window is where Hawaii departs from the anniversary-month pattern most states follow. The Division assigns every registered entity to one of four filing quarters based on the calendar quarter in which the entity was originally organized or first qualified in Hawaii. An LLC organized between January 1 and March 31 files its annual report each year by March 31 (quarter one). April through June formations file by June 30 (quarter two). July through September by September 30 (quarter three). October through December, including the late-November filer this guide is addressed to, file by December 31 (quarter four) of each subsequent calendar year. An LLC organized on November 26, 2019 files its first annual report by December 31, 2020, and every December 31 thereafter.

The form asks for a handful of current fields: the principal office address, the registered agent, the member or manager of record, and a general description of the LLC's nature of business. If nothing has changed since the last filing, the report is a minute of confirmation. Hawaii Business Express handles the whole cycle in the browser; the state will send an electronic reminder to the email on file roughly thirty days before the deadline, and a second one in the final ten days.

Miss the deadline and the Division begins an administrative-dissolution track under § 428-809. The LLC first receives written notice of the delinquency. If the report is not filed and the delinquency cured within the statutory notice window, the Division administratively dissolves the LLC, which means the entity loses its authority to conduct business in Hawaii and leaves its members exposed on anything that happens during the dissolution window that the liability shield would otherwise have covered. Reinstatement is available under § 428-810 upon filing the delinquent report or reports and paying a reinstatement fee, but the period between dissolution and reinstatement is a live question in any subsequent suit, and Hawaii courts have not drawn as clean a retroactive-shield line as some sister jurisdictions.

For an LLC forming in the fourth quarter, there is a tactical footnote. An October or November 2019 formation files its first report in December 2020, a full year out. A late December 2019 formation files in December 2020 as well, which can mean a first report ten days after organization rather than a year after. The DCCA does not penalize late-year formation with a compressed first cycle, but a December 29 organizer who forgets the calendar quarter can face a first-report deadline that arrives faster than expected. File when the entity is needed; note the quarter on the way out.

The General Excise Tax, which is not a sales tax

The tax that shapes how a Hawaii LLC actually operates is not on the DCCA's fee schedule. It is the General Excise Tax, administered by the Department of Taxation under Haw. Rev. Stat. Chapter 237, and it is one of the structural reasons Hawaii tax practice runs on its own assumptions.

The GET looks like a sales tax at a glance and is not one. A sales tax is imposed on the buyer and collected by the seller as a pass-through. The GET is a tax on the privilege of doing business in Hawaii; it is imposed on the seller, on the seller's gross receipts, and it applies to essentially every dollar of business income sourced to the state across industries and transaction types. Retail sales of tangible personal property, services, rents, commissions, interest, professional fees, and contracting receipts all fall inside the GET base. Most states exempt at least half of that list from their sales tax; Hawaii does not.

The state base rate is 4%. Three of the four counties impose a 0.5% surcharge on top: Honolulu County (the City and County of Honolulu, which covers the whole island of Oahu) at 4.5%, Kauai County at 4.5%, and Hawaii County (the Big Island) at 4.5%. Maui County is the one county that has not adopted the surcharge, and GET on Maui-sourced receipts runs at the unadorned 4%. A Honolulu-based consulting LLC billing a Honolulu client runs the combined 4.5% rate on the gross invoice; the same LLC billing a Maui client on Maui-sourced work runs the 4% rate.

The second structural difference is the wholesale rule. A conventional sales tax exempts business-to-business transactions at the wholesale level and imposes the full rate only at retail, because the tax is meant to fall on the final consumer. The GET does not exempt wholesale. It taxes wholesale transactions at a reduced 0.5% rate under § 237-13, which sounds nominal and compounds aggressively. A Hawaii importer selling to a Hawaii retailer pays 0.5% on the wholesale sale; the retailer then pays 4% or 4.5% on the retail sale; the end price carries layered GET in a way a sales-tax regime would not produce. The practical effect is that goods move through Hawaii at a slightly higher cost than the headline rate suggests, and the pricing conventions in many Hawaii industries have been built around the expectation that the GET is a cost of doing business passed through to the customer on the invoice as a separately stated line.

The GET filing cadence is monthly for most taxpayers, quarterly for smaller ones, and semi-annual at the very bottom. The first GET task for a newly formed Hawaii LLC is obtaining a GET license from the Department of Taxation using Form BB-1, which runs a one-time $20 license fee. Every Hawaii LLC with any in-state receipts needs one, including single-member consulting LLCs that most mainland founders would not think of as tax filers beyond the federal return.

Income tax, which is the highest top rate in the country

Hawaii's individual income tax runs on a graduated schedule that starts at 1.4% on the lowest taxable-income band and climbs through twelve brackets to 11% at the top, per the Department of Taxation's 2019 rate schedule under Haw. Rev. Stat. § 235-51. The 11% top bracket is the highest headline rate of any state in the country as of late 2019; only California's 13.3% at the $1 million threshold rivals it, and California's top kicks in far above where Hawaii's does. For a pass-through LLC with profitable Hawaii-resident members, the member-level rate is a material input to the annual liability and a reason many higher-earning Hawaii operators look closely at a C-corp election despite the usual pass-through defaults.

The corporate side is less painful on its face. Hawaii's corporate income tax under Haw. Rev. Stat. § 235-71 runs graduated across three brackets: 4.4% on the first $25,000 of taxable income, 5.4% on the next band to $100,000, and 6.4% above that. A Hawaii LLC that elects C-corp treatment for federal purposes sits inside the 6.4% state rate on the bulk of taxable income, on top of the federal 21% corporate rate set by the Tax Cuts and Jobs Act. The combined federal-plus-state corporate rate lands just over 27% on Hawaii taxable income, which is the number to run against the pass-through alternative when the member-level rate is deep in the 9% to 11% range. For a high-margin Hawaii professional services practice, the C-corp election can pencil even after accounting for the dividend layer, provided retained earnings have a genuine business reuse.

The Section 199A qualified business income deduction complicates the comparison in the usual way. Hawaii conforms to Section 199A at the federal-taxable-income starting point under § 235-2.3, so the 20% deduction flows through to a Hawaii member's federal taxable income and indirectly lowers the federal layer before the Hawaii state rate is calculated. Hawaii does not add a state-level 199A haircut. A Hawaii LLC owner in a non-specified-service trade, below the income thresholds, is picking up the full federal deduction without a state-level offset.

Who forming in Hawaii actually makes sense for

Hawaii makes sense for founders operating in Hawaii. That is the honest answer, and it covers the overwhelming majority of legitimate Hawaii filings. A Honolulu law practice, a Maui boutique operation, a Kauai vacation-rental holding LLC, and a Big Island farm reorganization are all better off forming at home than paying two states for the privilege of a Delaware or Wyoming charter and foreign-qualifying back. The GET follows the receipts either way; the only thing foreign qualification adds is a second state's fee schedule. For the broader analysis of that tradeoff, see how to choose a state when you don't live there.

Hawaii makes sense for a Hawaii real-estate portfolio. The statute is mature, the liability shield follows standard uniform-act rules, and the annual compliance is $15. For a holding structure containing Hawaii real property, Hawaii is the right place for the upper box, full stop. The GET on rental receipts applies regardless of where the entity is chartered, which removes the usual out-of-state-shell incentive.

Hawaii does not make sense for a venture-backed software company. Institutional investors raising a priced round will ask for a Delaware C-corp, and if they do not, their counsel will. Starting in Hawaii and converting to Delaware later is a four-figure legal and tax exercise and a scar on the cap table. Founders who know they are headed into the venture pipeline should form Delaware on day one, operate from Hawaii, and foreign-qualify back as a Delaware entity doing business in Hawaii. The GET still applies to Hawaii-sourced receipts; the state-of-formation decision does not change that.

Hawaii does not make sense as a tax-haven destination for non-Hawaii operators. The 11% top individual rate is the highest in the country, and the GET's wholesale reach means even structuring exercises that work in no-income-tax states do not replicate cleanly here. A founder looking for a low-tax wrapper is going to Wyoming or Nevada, not Hawaii.

The filing-quarter system is the operational quirk worth internalizing before the Articles are signed. A November 26 formation puts the LLC on the fourth-quarter cycle and every subsequent annual report on a December 31 deadline. For a single-member Hawaii LLC, that means a late-December calendar item that recurs every year for as long as the entity is on the rolls. A commercial registered agent will usually send a reminder; an in-house agent needs a docket entry set the week the Articles come back filed.

Sources

Keep reading

More from the journal.