Incorporator The Journal of U.S. Formation
Start Free Quiz
Editorial 8 MIN READ

How to do a check-the-box election without breaking anything

Form 8832, the 75-day rule, and the 60-month lockout that quietly kills bad timing

The Editors
Staff, Incorporator.org
8 min read Updated
Contents 9 sections
  1. What the election actually does
  2. The defaults, and why most people should understand them before electing
  3. The 75-day retro rule and the 12-month forward rule
  4. The 60-month lockout
  5. The S-election shortcut
  6. When you miss the deadline
  7. The CTA overlay nobody mentioned in 2016
  8. A short worked example
  9. Sources

he check-the-box election is a single-page IRS form that changes how the federal government taxes your business without changing what your business is under state law. You file Form 8832, you pick a classification, and the IRS treats your entity that way for federal purposes. That is the whole mechanic.

The rest of this piece is the fine print that trips people up: which entities can elect, the default rules that apply if you do nothing, the two date windows for when the election takes effect, the five-year lockout after a change, and the relief routes when you miss a deadline.

What the election actually does

Regulations under Treas. Reg. § 301.7701-3 let an eligible business entity choose whether to be treated as a corporation, a partnership, or (for a single owner) a disregarded entity for federal tax purposes. The election is made on Form 8832, Entity Classification Election. State law treatment does not move. An LLC that checks the box to be taxed as a C-corp remains an LLC with its state; the IRS just runs the entity through Subchapter C instead of Subchapter K or Schedule C.

Not every entity gets to elect. Treas. Reg. § 301.7701-2(b) lists per se corporations that are always taxed as corporations regardless of what anyone files. The list includes entities formed under a federal or state statute that refers to the entity as incorporated, a corporation, or a body corporate, joint-stock companies, insurance companies, state chartered banks insured by the FDIC, and a long enumeration of foreign business entities treated as per se corporations by name (S.A., AG, GmbH, PLC, and so on, by country). If your entity is on that list, Form 8832 is not available to you. The election is for "eligible entities," which in practice means domestic LLCs, partnerships, and most foreign entities not on the per se list.

The defaults, and why most people should understand them before electing

If an eligible entity does nothing, Treas. Reg. § 301.7701-3(b) applies a default classification. A domestic eligible entity with a single owner is disregarded as separate from its owner. A domestic eligible entity with two or more members is a partnership. A foreign eligible entity's default depends on whether any member has limited liability; the rules are in § 301.7701-3(b)(2) and are worth reading slowly if you are dealing with a non-U.S. vehicle.

For most U.S. founders, this means the default is already what they want. A solo-owned LLC is disregarded, which means the owner reports the LLC's activity on Schedule C (or Schedule E, or Form 1040 Schedule F, depending on the activity) and there is no separate entity-level return. A two-member LLC files Form 1065 and issues K-1s. Neither requires Form 8832. You file Form 8832 only when you want something other than the default, typically when an LLC wants corporate treatment, or when a previously-elected corporate LLC wants to go back.

The common shape of a check-the-box election is therefore: an LLC electing to be taxed as a C-corp, or an LLC electing S-corp treatment (which is technically a two-step path, and is covered below).

The 75-day retro rule and the 12-month forward rule

Form 8832 asks for an effective date. Treas. Reg. § 301.7701-3(c)(1)(iii) limits how far that date can be from the filing date. The election can be effective up to 75 days before the date the form is filed, and up to 12 months after the date the form is filed. If you enter a date outside that window, the IRS uses the filing date (or, if the out-of-window date is in the future, the date 12 months after filing).

The 75-day backward window is the one that matters most in practice. It is what lets a founder who formed in October and only realized in December that they wanted C-corp treatment make the election retroactive to the formation date, so that the entity was never a disregarded entity or partnership for federal purposes. Miss the 75-day window by a week and you are looking at late-election relief, discussed below.

The 12-month forward window is useful when timing matters for a transaction. If you want the classification change to land on the first day of the next tax year, you file now and put that date in box 8.

The 60-month lockout

Once an eligible entity makes an election under § 301.7701-3(c)(1)(i), it cannot make another election to change its classification for 60 months after the effective date of the prior election. That rule is in Treas. Reg. § 301.7701-3(c)(1)(iv). It is the sharpest edge of the whole regime, because it means a flip to C-corp and then an attempt to flip back to partnership two years later is simply not honored; the entity stays a C-corp for federal purposes whether you want it to or not.

There is one escape valve in the same regulation. The 60-month limitation does not apply if more than 50 percent of the ownership interests in the entity as of the effective date of the subsequent election are owned by persons that did not own any interests in the entity on the effective date (or the filing date, if later) of the prior election. A real change of ownership unlocks the door; a reorganization among the same owners does not.

One more wrinkle worth naming: an initial election by a newly formed eligible entity, made effective on the date of formation, is not counted as a change for purposes of § 301.7701-3(c)(1)(iv). The 60-month clock starts only when you move off the default.

The S-election shortcut

An LLC that wants to be taxed as an S corporation technically needs two elections: a check-the-box election to be treated as a corporation, and an S-election on Form 2553 to switch the corporate entity into Subchapter S. Rev. Proc. 2004-48 folds these together for eligible entities. A timely and properly filed Form 2553 by an eligible entity is deemed to include the Form 8832 election to be classified as an association taxable as a corporation. You file one form and the IRS treats it as two. The procedure lists the conditions: the entity must meet the requirements to be an S corporation, the effective date on Form 2553 must be the same for both elections, and the entity must otherwise be eligible to elect corporate treatment.

The practical reading: if an LLC is going S, file Form 2553 and only Form 2553. Do not also file an 8832 for the same effective date; Rev. Proc. 2004-48 was designed to spare you the belt-and-suspenders filing, and double filing can introduce its own reconciliation problems.

When you miss the deadline

Miss the 75-day window and the primary relief route is Rev. Proc. 2009-41. It gives an eligible entity up to three years and 75 days after the requested effective date to request relief for a late classification election, provided the entity has reasonable cause for the late filing, the entity has either filed consistently with the requested classification (or has not yet filed a return for the first year for which the election was intended), and the entity meets the other conditions laid out in section 4 of the revenue procedure. You file Form 8832 with "FILED PURSUANT TO REV. PROC. 2009-41" written across the top and a reasonable-cause statement attached.

Reasonable cause is not a high bar, but it is not nothing. "My CPA forgot" has carried the day in many cases; "I changed my mind after running the numbers" has not. Write the statement as if a revenue agent will read it, because one will.

If you are outside the three years and 75 days, the remaining route is a private letter ruling under Treas. Reg. §§ 301.9100-1 and 301.9100-3. That regulation lets the Commissioner grant an extension of time to make a regulatory election where the taxpayer acted reasonably and in good faith and granting relief will not prejudice the interests of the government. The user fee for a PLR in this area runs into the thousands, and preparation by counsel runs higher. It is a real option but an expensive one; Rev. Proc. 2009-41 is the door you want to use if you can.

A parallel late-election route exists for S-elections specifically under Rev. Proc. 2013-30, which consolidates several earlier procedures. If the underlying issue is a missed S-election rather than a missed classification election, 2013-30 is the relevant text.

The CTA overlay nobody mentioned in 2016

Form 8832 is a federal tax mechanic; it has historically had no reporting crossover with other agencies. That changed with the Corporate Transparency Act, codified at 31 U.S.C. § 5336, which requires most U.S. entities to file beneficial ownership information with FinCEN. A check-the-box election by itself does not create a new reporting company under the CTA, because the entity under state law is unchanged. But a classification election is often paired with other moves, such as issuing new equity to bring in a partner to break the 60-month lockout, or merging the LLC into a new corporation to achieve a cleaner tax posture, and those moves can change the beneficial ownership picture. When the underlying ownership or control has shifted, an updated BOI report is due within 30 days under § 5336(b)(1)(D). Do not let the federal tax side of the election eat the FinCEN deadline on the state-law side.

A short worked example

A two-member Delaware LLC formed in March has been running as a partnership by default. In November the members decide they want C-corp treatment retroactive to January 1 so that losses from the first calendar year run through the corporate regime. November 15 is 319 days after January 1, well outside the 75-day retro window, so a straight Form 8832 with a January 1 effective date will not work. Two routes remain: file Form 8832 with a November 15 effective date (losing the first ten and a half months), or file under Rev. Proc. 2009-41 with a January 1 effective date and a reasonable-cause statement, provided the entity has not yet filed a Form 1065 for the year. The second route only works if the entity genuinely has not filed; if the partnership return is already in, the reasonable-cause argument falls apart, because the return is inconsistent with the requested classification.

The rule of thumb: decide the federal tax classification before the entity has done anything the IRS has seen, and if you must change it later, move within 75 days or be ready to defend reasonable cause.

Sources

Keep reading

More from the journal.