Incorporator The Journal of U.S. Formation
Start Free Quiz
Editorial 7 MIN READ

How to read a Delaware franchise tax notice without panicking

The six-figure bill on the first page is almost always wrong, and the statute tells you how to fix it

The Editors
Staff, Incorporator.org
7 min read Updated
Contents 7 sections
  1. The two methods, straight from Title 8
  2. Authorized Shares math
  3. Assumed Par Value Capital math
  4. Why the notice prints the scarier number
  5. Deadlines, penalties, and the annual report
  6. How to actually read the notice
  7. Sources

he Delaware franchise tax notice that lands on a newly minted C-corp in February usually quotes a number in the mid five figures, occasionally six. It is almost always wrong in the sense that the startup does not owe that amount. It is right in the narrow sense that Delaware prints the larger of the two statutory methods on the notice by default, and the larger of the two methods for a venture-shaped cap table is absurd.

This is a field guide for reading that notice. If you finish this piece you will know which number to ignore, which number to compute, and how the statute actually works.

The two methods, straight from Title 8

Delaware's franchise tax for stock corporations is set out in Subchapter VI of the General Corporation Law, 8 Del. C. sections 501 through 519. Section 503 is the operative provision: it defines the two alternative methods by which the tax is calculated and tells the Secretary of State which one to bill.

The first method is the Authorized Shares method. It looks only at how many shares your certificate of incorporation authorizes, not how many are outstanding, not their par value, not the company's revenue or assets. The second method is the Assumed Par Value Capital method (APVC). It looks at a blended figure derived from total gross assets, total issued shares, and authorized shares by class. Section 503(a) defines both. Section 503(c) gives the taxpayer the right to elect the lower of the two. The notice prints the Authorized Shares result because that is the default computation the state runs first.

The economic point of having two methods is that each is a rough proxy for something the state might reasonably tax. Authorized shares is a proxy for the size of the equity charter the state granted you. Assumed par value capital is a proxy for the capital actually deployed. A startup with a huge share authorization and almost no assets will score very differently under the two formulas, and section 503(c) lets it pay the smaller bill.

Authorized Shares math

The Authorized Shares schedule under section 503(a)(1) is a step function. For a corporation authorized to issue 5,000 shares or fewer, the minimum tax is $175. From 5,001 to 10,000 authorized shares, the tax is $250. Above 10,000, the tax is $250 plus $85 for each additional 10,000 shares or fraction thereof, up to a maximum tax of $250,000 for most filers. (Large corporate filers, defined in section 503(c) of the 2017 amendments, top out higher; that tier does not apply to startups.)

Run the math on a typical venture-backed incorporation. A Delaware C-corp that authorizes 10,000,000 shares of common stock to support founder issuances, option pool, and seed round dilution falls far up the step function. The first 10,000 shares cost $250. The remaining 9,990,000 shares, rounded up to the next 10,000 increment, generate 999 additional $85 increments. That is $250 plus (999 times $85), which is $250 plus $84,915, for a total of $85,165.

This is the number the notice prints. It is also the number that causes the founder to call their lawyer in a mild panic.

Assumed Par Value Capital math

The APVC method, section 503(a)(2), runs differently. You start with a number called assumed par value capital, which is computed in a multi-step way the statute lays out. In rough terms: you take total gross assets from the corporation's federal tax return for the year, divide by total issued shares to get an assumed par, apply that assumed par to each class of stock up to its authorized count, and sum. The tax is then $400 per $1,000,000 of assumed par value capital, with a floor of $400.

The same 10,000,000-share startup, say it raised a $2 million seed round, has issued 8 million shares to founders at $0.00001 par, and has $1.8 million in gross assets at year end. Working through 503(a)(2): the assumed par, computed from $1.8 million divided by 8 million issued shares, comes in around $0.225, which exceeds the actual par of $0.00001, so the statute uses $0.225 as the assumed par. Assumed par value capital is then that figure multiplied by the authorized count of 10 million, yielding roughly $2.25 million. Apply the $400 per $1 million rate and you get about $900.

For most early-stage companies with assets below the round size and modest authorized counts relative to issued, the APVC result lands between the $400 floor and somewhere in the low thousands. The contrast with the Authorized Shares default is the whole story. $85,165 becomes roughly $400 to $500 for many zero-revenue startups, and a few thousand for seed-stage companies with a year of runway in the bank.

Why the notice prints the scarier number

Delaware mails the notice in late January with the Authorized Shares figure on line 1 because that is the computation the state can perform without asking the corporation for its gross assets. The APVC computation requires the taxpayer to fill in the gross-assets field, the issued-shares field, and the per-class authorized-shares field on the annual report form. Until the taxpayer files the annual report with those numbers, the state has only the authorized count from the charter, and the Authorized Shares method is the only one that runs on that input alone.

This is not a trap in the statute. Section 503(c) explicitly tells the taxpayer they may compute and pay under the lower method; the Division of Corporations' online filing portal recomputes the tax in real time as you type the APVC inputs and lets you submit the lower number. The trap, if there is one, is in the mail. A founder who sees "$85,165 due" and does not know about section 503(c) will sometimes wire it. Delaware will cash the check.

Deadlines, penalties, and the annual report

The franchise tax and the annual report are joined: you file the report and pay the tax at the same time, through the same portal. Section 502(a) requires every domestic corporation to file an annual report on or before March 1 each year, covering the preceding calendar year. The tax is due on the same date.

Miss it and section 502(c) imposes a $200 late penalty plus interest at 1.5 percent per month on the unpaid balance. The interest compounds monthly. A corporation that forgets March 1 and pays in December owes the original tax, plus $200, plus roughly 13.5 percent in accrued interest on the tax (not on the penalty). For a company paying the $400 APVC minimum, that is $600 plus change. For a company that wired the $85,165 Authorized Shares number and later discovered it overpaid, refunds are possible but slow; the cleaner path is to recompute before March 1 and pay the lower figure the first time.

Failure to file for two consecutive years causes the Secretary of State to declare the charter void under section 510. Reviving a voided charter costs the back taxes, the accumulated penalties and interest, plus a reinstatement fee, and it blocks ordinary business acts like closing financings or signing commercial contracts until the revival clears. This is the real downside, not the headline tax number.

How to actually read the notice

Open the notice. Find the Authorized Shares figure; ignore it for now. Find the line that asks for total gross assets as of the end of the fiscal year. If the company has audited or reviewed financials, use the total-assets line from the balance sheet. If not, use the figure from Form 1120, Schedule L, line 15 (total assets). Find the total issued shares as of December 31 (not authorized, not outstanding-plus-options; issued and outstanding on the books). Enter those into the portal.

The portal computes APVC in real time and shows both numbers side by side. Pay the lower one. File the annual report at the same transaction. Keep the confirmation.

If the portal's APVC number is still uncomfortably high, the likely cause is that authorized shares dwarf issued shares by a factor large enough to inflate assumed par value capital. The fix is a charter amendment reducing authorized shares, filed under section 242. Most startups do not need 10 million authorized at incorporation; 5 million is usually enough until the Series A, and the franchise-tax savings across the first few years often exceed the amendment fee.

One-line rule of thumb: if the notice is more than a few thousand dollars and the company has not raised a Series B, you are reading the wrong method; recompute under APVC before paying.

Sources

Keep reading

More from the journal.