Incorporator The Journal of U.S. Formation
Start Free Quiz
Editorial 6 MIN READ

Minnesota in mid-2022: the cheapest annual renewal in the country, paired with one of the steepest corporate rates

What it costs to form an LLC in Minnesota, what it costs to keep one, and the tax number that reshapes the calculus for anyone choosing an entity type

The Editors
Staff, Incorporator.org
6 min read Updated
Contents 6 sections
  1. The mechanics
  2. Annual renewal: free, and a trap
  3. The tax side is where Minnesota earns its reputation
  4. Versus Delaware, in dollars
  5. Who this state actually makes sense for
  6. Sources

innesota charges $155 to form an LLC online, $135 in person, and nothing at all to renew it each year. That last number is unusual enough to be the thing most people remember, and also the one that gets the most people dissolved.

The rest of the picture is less forgiving. Minnesota runs a flat corporate franchise tax of 9.8%, the highest flat corporate rate in the country, and a top individual rate of 9.85%. The formation math is cheap; the operating math is not.

The mechanics

Minnesota LLCs are creatures of Chapter 322C of the Minnesota Statutes, the state's adoption of the Revised Uniform Limited Liability Company Act. You form one by filing Articles of Organization with the Office of the Secretary of State. The document is short: the LLC name (which must include "Limited Liability Company," "LLC," or "L.L.C."), the registered office address in Minnesota, the name of a registered agent if you want one separate from the office, the name and address of at least one organizer, and an email for official notices.

Filing fees are set by Minn. Stat. § 5.001 and published on the Secretary of State's fee schedule. Online and in-person expedited filing is $155. Filing by mail is $135. The difference is not a convenience charge; it is the expedited fee built in to the over-the-counter channel. Most filers use the online portal and have a confirmed entity the same business day.

You will also want an EIN from the IRS (free, same-day via Form SS-4 online), an operating agreement (not filed, not required by statute, but assumed by 322C and referenced throughout its default-rule sections), and a decision about federal tax classification. The default is disregarded for single-member LLCs and partnership for multi-member LLCs, with S-corp or C-corp elections available via Form 2553 or Form 8832.

Annual renewal: free, and a trap

Every Minnesota business entity must file an annual renewal with the Secretary of State each calendar year. For LLCs in good standing, the renewal fee is $0. You file it, you confirm your registered office and agent, and you move on.

The deadline is December 31. Miss it and the statute is not gentle. Under Minn. Stat. § 322C.0705, an LLC that fails to file its annual renewal is administratively dissolved by the Secretary of State in the following calendar year. Reinstatement requires filing the delinquent renewal together with a reinstatement fee of $25 (or $45 by mail). During the dissolved period, the LLC loses its good-standing status, its ability to maintain suit in Minnesota courts, and in some cases the limited liability protection its members thought they were paying for.

The comparison writes itself. Delaware charges $300 a year and sends a June notice that many founders throw away. Minnesota charges $0 and sends a December notice that many founders also throw away. The paperwork is the same in both cases; only the dollar figure differs. Free is not a reason to skip the calendar reminder.

The tax side is where Minnesota earns its reputation

Minnesota's corporate franchise tax is set by Minn. Stat. § 290.06, subd. 1, at a flat 9.8% of Minnesota-apportioned taxable income. That is the highest flat corporate rate any state imposes. A handful of states have higher top marginal rates in their brackets (New Jersey's 11.5% on income over $1 million sits above it), but on a flat-rate basis, Minnesota is first.

The individual side is not much softer. The top individual bracket under Minn. Stat. § 290.06, subd. 2c, reaches 9.85%, applicable for tax year 2022 to married-joint taxable income above $284,810 and single filers above $171,220. Pass-through income from an LLC taxed as a partnership or a disregarded entity lands here, on the owners' Minnesota returns.

The federal $10,000 cap on state and local tax deductions under IRC § 164(b)(6) (added by the Tax Cuts and Jobs Act) made that 9.85% rate visible in a way it had not been before. Minnesota responded with a pass-through entity (PTE) tax election, enacted as part of HF 9 in the 2021 First Special Session, codified at Minn. Stat. § 289A.08, subd. 7a. The election is effective for tax years beginning after December 31, 2020, meaning the first year on the books is TY 2021 and the first large wave of elections arrived during 2022 filing season.

The mechanics: a qualifying partnership or S-corp (including an LLC taxed as either) elects to pay Minnesota income tax at the entity level. The entity deducts that tax federally as a business expense under IRC § 164, sidestepping the individual SALT cap. Owners receive a full Minnesota credit for their share of the entity-paid tax. The IRS blessed the structure in Notice 2020-75, which confirmed that specified income-tax payments by partnerships and S-corps are deductible in computing non-separately-stated income. For Minnesota owners in the top bracket, the election is usually worth the filing complexity.

Single-member LLCs that have not elected S-corp treatment are disregarded entities and therefore cannot make the PTE election. That is a real structural disadvantage of the default single-member form in Minnesota relative to neighboring states with lower individual rates.

Versus Delaware, in dollars

Run the five-year comparison on a two-person LLC operating in Minnesota.

Delaware formation: $90 under 8 Del. C. § 18-1105. Delaware annual tax: $300 a year, due June 1, under 6 Del. C. § 18-1107(b). Delaware registered agent, required under 6 Del. C. § 18-104: $100 to $300 a year at commercial providers. Delaware five-year cost for a non-operating holding entity: roughly $1,590 to $2,590, plus the registered-agent markup forever.

And then, because the LLC is operating in Minnesota, it must register as a foreign LLC with the Minnesota Secretary of State. That is a Certificate of Authority filing at $205 online, plus the same annual Minnesota renewal obligation. The Delaware structure becomes a Minnesota structure with a Delaware surcharge.

Minnesota-only formation: $155 online. Annual renewal: $0. Five-year cost to keep a domestic Minnesota LLC on the rolls, excluding taxes: $155 total. That is cheaper than a single year in Delaware.

The tax picture flips the calculus. A Minnesota LLC earning income gets hit with 9.85% at the individual level, or 9.8% at the entity level if taxed as a C-corp, or 9.85% via the PTE election with the SALT workaround available. A Delaware LLC operating in Minnesota pays the same Minnesota tax, because Minnesota apportions on where the revenue is earned, not where the entity was organized. The Delaware filing fee does nothing to reduce the Minnesota tax bill.

Who this state actually makes sense for

If you are forming an LLC to run a business that operates in Minnesota, form it in Minnesota. The formation cost is competitive with the cheapest states, the renewal is free, and Chapter 322C is a modern, well-drafted LLC act. Any out-of-state formation is a foreign registration away from the same tax obligation with a second set of paperwork.

If the business is venture-backable and you expect institutional money inside the year, the old default still holds: form the operating entity as a Delaware C-corp from the start, because the conversion later is more expensive than the two annual Delaware taxes you will pay in the meantime.

If you are a passive-holding or estate-planning vehicle with no Minnesota nexus, Minnesota is not the right state; a lower-tax jurisdiction is. The reason to be here is that the business is here.

The single operational habit that matters most in Minnesota is the December renewal. It is free, it takes five minutes, and the number of administrative dissolutions the Secretary of State processes every spring suggests that "free" is, for many filers, a weaker forcing function than "$300."

Sources

Keep reading

More from the journal.