Incorporator The Journal of U.S. Formation
Start Free Quiz
Editorial 11 MIN READ

Sole proprietorship, a 2020 field report

Twenty months after the TCJA math changed, a pandemic loan program rewrote the Schedule C story inside eight confusing weeks

The Editors
Staff, Incorporator.org
11 min read Updated
Contents 6 sections
  1. What the April guidance got wrong, and what FAQ 32 fixed
  2. The math for a real Schedule C filer
  3. The LLC-conversion question nobody drafted an answer for
  4. What the 2020 wage base and the SE-tax deferral do to the bill
  5. The original frame is still the frame
  6. Sources

sole proprietor who reported $60,000 of net profit on the 2019 Schedule C can, as of this summer, borrow roughly $12,500 from a federally guaranteed lender, spend it on anything that looks like owner compensation over twenty-four weeks, and apply to have the loan forgiven. That sentence did not describe the sole proprietorship at any point before April 2020, and the path the Small Business Administration took to make it true is the reason a program that was supposed to close June 30 is now open through August with a shelf of guidance no one has finished reading.

This is a field report on the sole proprietorship, written in early August 2020, twenty months after the post-TCJA read and twelve weeks into a loan program that most Schedule C filers were eligible for by default and told the opposite for the first ten days. The original frame, from the 2017 article, is still the frame: no filing, no shield, self-employment tax on top. What changed is that federal relief aimed at payrolled businesses reached the self-employed through a calculation the agency had to publish twice before lenders would write against it.

What the April guidance got wrong, and what FAQ 32 fixed

The Paycheck Protection Program was authorized by § 1102 of the Coronavirus Aid, Relief, and Economic Security Act (Pub. L. 116-136, enacted March 27, 2020) and funded with an initial $349 billion. The statute defined eligible borrowers to include "individuals who operate under a sole proprietorship or as an independent contractor," which by its plain text put every Schedule C filer on the same footing as a small business with employees. The mechanics of how that would work were left to SBA and Treasury.

The first Interim Final Rule, dated April 2 and published at 85 Fed. Reg. 20811 on April 15, told non-employer sole proprietors they would be eligible beginning April 10, one week after the program opened for businesses with employees. That seven-day staggering meant that by the time a typical freelance designer could apply, the banks she had a relationship with had already exhausted their lending capacity for the week. That was the first operational failure. The second was the guidance itself.

The April 14 IFR instructed self-employed applicants to compute loan size based on 2019 net earnings from self-employment "as reported on IRS Form 1040 Schedule C line 31, net profit." It capped any single individual's compensation component at $100,000 annualized, which meant that a proprietor with more than $100,000 of 2019 net profit got a loan sized on $100,000 divided by twelve times 2.5, or $20,833. So far so arithmetically clean.

The confusion came in the forgiveness rules. The same IFR said that a self-employed borrower's "owner compensation replacement" during the eight-week covered period would be limited to eight weeks' worth of 2019 net profit, capped at $15,385 (that is $100,000 times 8/52). It did not, in its first pass, clearly say whether any proof of that spending was required beyond the 2019 Schedule C itself. Lenders, who had just been trained on rigorous payroll-register documentation for employer borrowers, refused to process forgiveness applications from sole props until the agency answered. Community Facebook groups filled with contradictory readings from tax preparers. The Treasury hotline routed callers to the SBA, which routed them back.

The fix was SBA and Treasury's PPP FAQ #32, released April 24, 2020. It confirmed that net profit from Schedule C line 31 is the measure of the sole proprietor's owner compensation, that no separate documentation of weekly draws is required for the owner-compensation portion of forgiveness, and that the 2019 Schedule C (or a 2019 draft, if the return had not yet been filed) supplies the full evidentiary basis for both loan sizing and forgiveness of that share. The FAQ did not modify the IFR; it clarified it. Lenders took the clarification as sufficient cover to start approving forgiveness applications from self-employed borrowers, though most told those borrowers to wait for the final forgiveness form, which SBA released May 15 as Form 3508 and simplified June 16 as Form 3508EZ.

The FAQ 32 moment is worth naming because it is the only time in the program's first quarter that a piece of one-paragraph guidance unlocked a category of borrowers the statute had already covered. It is also the reason a sole proprietor reading about PPP in May was reading something materially different from the same program described in April.

The math for a real Schedule C filer

Take a freelance editor who reported $72,000 on line 31 of the 2019 Schedule C, filed Schedule SE, and paid self-employment tax under § 1401 at the familiar 15.3 percent combined rate (12.4 percent OASDI on the first $132,900 for 2019, $137,700 for 2020 per the Social Security Administration's Contribution and Benefit Base announcement, plus 2.9 percent Medicare with no cap).

PPP loan size: $72,000 / 12 × 2.5 = $15,000. That number is the maximum. Lenders may round conservatively. The loan sits in a designated business account or, for sole props without one, in a personal account flagged to the lender. The editor's 2019 return is the documentation; no payroll register, no 941, no state withholding confirmation.

Forgivable owner compensation over an eight-week covered period: $72,000 × 8 / 52 = $11,077. Over the twenty-four-week covered period added by the Paycheck Protection Program Flexibility Act of 2020 (Pub. L. 116-142, enacted June 5), the cap is the lesser of 2.5 months' net profit or $20,833. For a $72,000 filer, 2.5 months of 2019 net profit is $15,000, which matches the loan. The entire principal is structurally forgivable as owner compensation if the borrower keeps the loan for twenty-four weeks. Rent, utilities, and interest on pre-existing debt may be added as non-owner costs, but for a home-office sole prop they are typically small, and the owner-compensation line carries most of the weight.

The $72,000 Schedule C filer is not collecting enhanced unemployment through the same period she is collecting forgivable PPP. CARES § 2104's Federal Pandemic Unemployment Compensation and § 2102's Pandemic Unemployment Assistance for independent contractors overlap with PPP owner-compensation replacement, and the state unemployment agencies treat PPP weeks as weeks of earned income for weekly-benefit purposes. Double-dipping is not blocked at the federal level, but it is reconciled at the state claim level, and at least one state (New York) has been clawing back PUA weeks covered by PPP owner compensation since June. The field-report caveat: take one or the other, cleanly, and document which weeks fall where.

The LLC-conversion question nobody drafted an answer for

A sole proprietor with an open PPP loan who forms an LLC in June or July, with the intention of running the balance of 2020 through the new entity, is holding a small procedural puzzle. The loan is made to the sole proprietor as an individual, documented with her Social Security number on the application and tied to her 2019 Schedule C. The LLC, once formed, is a separate legal person under the relevant state statute, though if she is the sole member and does nothing else, the IRS treats it as a disregarded entity for federal tax purposes under Reg. § 301.7701-3(b)(1)(ii), and her business income continues to land on her Schedule C.

Does the new LLC assume the PPP loan? SBA has not issued formal guidance on this specific conversion. What it has issued, in a procedural notice dated July 23, 2020, is a change-of-ownership rule requiring SBA consent before any sale of fifty percent or more of the borrower's assets while the loan is outstanding. A sole proprietor who transfers her book of business into a single-member LLC she wholly owns is not selling assets to a third party, and the disregarded-entity treatment means the federal tax filer does not change. The conservative reading, which most SBA-lending counsel are taking in August, is that the loan stays with the individual borrower, the LLC operates alongside it, and the forgiveness application is filed by the individual on the basis of the same 2019 Schedule C that sized the loan. Income earned through the LLC after formation is the LLC's income for state-law purposes and the sole member's Schedule C income for federal tax purposes, without breaking the PPP chain.

A sole proprietor who intends to elect S-corp treatment for the new LLC creates a harder problem. The S-election converts the entity from disregarded to a separate taxpayer filing Form 1120-S; the owner becomes a W-2 employee; the 2020 Schedule C for the proprietorship effectively stops when the election takes effect. Running that election mid-covered-period is the sort of structural move that the July 23 notice suggests SBA may treat as a change of ownership even within one economic owner. The practical advice from lenders in August is to wait: keep the PPP loan on the individual, finish the covered period, submit forgiveness, then convert. The cost of waiting two to three months is real (one more quarter of self-employment tax at 15.3 percent on the wage-equivalent portion of earnings) and bounded; the cost of triggering a PPP compliance review is not.

What the 2020 wage base and the SE-tax deferral do to the bill

The 2020 Social Security Contribution and Benefit Base is $137,700, up from $132,900 in 2019, per SSA's October 2019 announcement. For a sole proprietor, that is the ceiling on the 12.4 percent OASDI portion of SE tax. The 2.9 percent Medicare portion still has no ceiling, and the 0.9 percent Additional Medicare Tax under IRC § 3101(b)(2) still applies above $200,000 single or $250,000 joint.

A proprietor netting $140,000 in 2020 pays SE tax on 92.35 percent of that ($129,290), with OASDI capped at $137,700 of the underlying earnings base (which her 92.35 percent adjustment keeps her under), and Medicare running to the top of the number. The SE-tax bill is roughly $19,781 before the deductible half-adjustment, with the § 199A deduction still available on qualified business income up to the $163,300 single / $326,600 joint thresholds announced in Rev. Proc. 2019-44 for 2020.

CARES § 2302 allows deferral of the employer-equivalent half of SE tax on net earnings earned between March 27 and December 31, 2020, with half due December 31, 2021 and half due December 31, 2022. For the $140,000 proprietor, that is roughly $4,891 of deferred cash, not avoided. Sole proprietors who took PPP and had it forgiven lost this deferral at the forgiveness date under the original CARES language; the Paycheck Protection Program Flexibility Act struck that limitation on June 5, and a PPP borrower may now defer the employer share of SE tax without regard to forgiveness. That legislative course-correction is the second time in three months Congress restored a benefit the original statute had blocked for self-employed borrowers.

The original frame is still the frame

What has not changed in 2020 is the shape of the sole proprietorship. There is still no formation document. The IRS still treats an individual conducting business without forming an entity as a sole proprietor, per its 2020 Publication 334, Tax Guide for Small Business (For Individuals Who Use Schedule C). Business income and expenses still land on Schedule C (Form 1040). Self-employment tax is still computed on Schedule SE. The quarterly estimated-tax obligation still runs under IRC § 6654, though the IRS in Notice 2020-18 and Notice 2020-23 pushed the April 15 and June 15, 2020 deadlines to July 15 as part of its COVID-response sequence.

The liability gap has not moved. A sole proprietor is personally liable for every debt and every tort of the business. A client lawsuit comes against her personally; a contract breach puts her personal assets at risk; a vehicle operated for the business on a delivery run exposes her house. Forming an LLC, which is the disregarded-entity conversion most proprietors should have made by now, costs between roughly $50 (Kentucky) and a few hundred dollars in most states and adds one annual filing; it preserves the Schedule C default if the sole member does nothing further.

The interesting question the pandemic posed, which will be asked again in the next crisis program, is whether federal emergency lending should run through the entity layer or through the individual tax return. PPP ran through both, awkwardly, with the employer payroll side working first and the self-employed side arriving second through a sequence of IFRs and FAQs. A future program built from scratch would probably accept Schedule C net profit as the self-employed analog of payroll from day one. Until then, the sole proprietor reading her 2019 return in the summer of 2020 is in the position of someone whose entity choice, made by default and never revisited, turned out to fit a specific policy moment she never anticipated. The form does that. It has always done that.

Sources

Keep reading

More from the journal.