Incorporator The Journal of U.S. Formation
Start Free Quiz
Editorial 10 MIN READ

The Secretary of State online filing portal, benchmarked in mid-2019

Who actually formed an LLC in a web browser this quarter, who mailed a PDF, and which states still wanted a trip to a probate judge

The Editors
Staff, Incorporator.org
10 min read Updated
Contents 7 sections
  1. What "online filing" actually means in 2019
  2. The same-day benchmark: Delaware, Texas, Wyoming, California
  3. The solid middle: Florida, Colorado, Ohio, Washington, Arizona, Michigan
  4. The laggards: New York, Alabama, Louisiana, Massachusetts
  5. What a serious online filing portal actually delivers
  6. A rule of thumb for practitioners
  7. Sources

n June 2019, a Delaware LLC can be formed online in under an hour for an extra $500, and a New York LLC still has to be delivered on paper or through a fax machine the Department of State politely calls a "facsimile service." Both are true the same week. The Secretary of State online filing portal is not one thing; it is fifty things at very different levels of maturity, and 2019 is the year the gap stopped being a curiosity and started deciding which state a busy lawyer picks on a Friday.

This is a benchmark, not a ranking. The question is not which state is cheapest (Incorporator.org has covered the fee math elsewhere) but which ones let you complete a formation inside a browser tab, what "online" actually means when a state says it, and how long you wait after you click submit.

What "online filing" actually means in 2019

There are four tiers a state can sit in, and conflating them is how founders end up with a paper Certificate of Formation they have to notarize and mail.

The top tier is a true end-to-end web application: you key the name and the registered agent into a form, you pay with a credit card, and a stamped certificate is generated and emailed to you. Delaware's eCorp, California's bizfile, Colorado's Secretary of State system, Florida's Sunbiz, Ohio Business Central, and Wyoming's filing system all qualify. In each case, the user can form an LLC without printing anything.

The second tier is a web portal that accepts a PDF upload. The PDF is the filing; the portal is mail replacement. Alabama's Secretary of State portal now works this way for the counties that have joined it. Louisiana's geauxBIZ accepts uploaded PDFs of the executed Articles of Organization after a 2019 change that backed off an earlier, more rigid template-only approach.

The third tier is an online form that produces a PDF the user has to print, sign, and mail back. Several states market this as "online filing." It saves a typewriter, not a trip to the post office.

The fourth tier is paper, with fax as a concession. New York, in mid-2019, is still mostly here for LLC formations, which a state with 20 million residents is notable for on its own.

The same-day benchmark: Delaware, Texas, Wyoming, California

Delaware's eCorp is the reference implementation everyone else is measured against. The Division of Corporations' fee schedule in 2019 lists One Hour Service at $1,000, Two Hour Service at $500, Same Day at $100 to $200 (document-type dependent), and Next Day at $50 to $100, each on top of the $90 formation fee. Same-day filings must be received by 2:00 PM Eastern; the two-hour tier cuts off at 7:00 PM; the one-hour tier holds the door open until 9:00 PM. The portal itself operates Monday through Thursday 7:45 AM to 11:59 PM ET and Fridays until 10:30 PM. Weekends are closed. A large share of the world's late-Friday deal-closings therefore happen on a clock Delaware sets, which is part of why corporate lawyers in New York learn the eCorp login before they learn their way to the coffee machine.

Texas's SOSDirect sits one notch below Delaware on expedited service and one notch above most states on routine turnaround. The standard LLC filing fee is $300 plus a 2.7% credit-card convenience fee on SOSDirect submissions. Under the Texas Business Organizations Code, expedited processing costs $25 additional and generally puts a filing on the reviewer's queue the same business day. The Secretary of State's "Nuts and Bolts" materials distributed at the 2019 practitioner sessions describe a routine two-hour turn on assumed-name filings and a sub-24-hour turn on most entity formations. SOSDirect has been online since 1997, and its aesthetic is honest about that. It works.

Wyoming's portal at wyobiz.wyo.gov forms an LLC for $102.40 after the 2.4% card fee ($100 state fee plus the processor margin). Wyoming has no expedited tier because the routine tier is already same-day during business hours. The state's pitch is privacy rather than speed, but speed is thrown in.

California's bizfile is the interesting new entrant. Secretary of State Alex Padilla's office launched the platform in January 2018 and added LLC formation in May 2018. By December 2018 the office reported 54,693 LLC submissions through the tool and an average of 308 per business day. That number matters because California had been, for most of the 2010s, the paper holdout among the large-filing states: an LLC-1 Articles of Organization was a fillable PDF that had to be mailed to Sacramento, with turnaround measured in weeks during filing-season peaks. The 2018 bizfile rollout brought California into the same-day club for the first time, and by mid-2019 roughly four out of five Statements of Information were being filed online rather than on paper. The Eureka chatbot the office deployed alongside the formation tool is a small detail but a telling one: it is the first state-side AI assistant for entity formation in production anywhere in the country.

The solid middle: Florida, Colorado, Ohio, Washington, Arizona, Michigan

Florida's Sunbiz has been quietly one of the strongest state portals for a decade. LLC formation is $125, the annual report is $138.75 with the May 1 deadline priced into everyone's calendar, and both happen inside a web browser with same-day confirmation during business hours. Sunbiz was the portal other states pointed at during their own rebuilds.

Colorado does not offer paper filing at all; the Secretary of State accepts online filings only. The LLC formation fee is $50, the periodic report is $10, and the state has leaned into online-only as a cost-control measure rather than a premium experience. The portal does not win on visual design, but turnaround is same-day and the state has no expedited tier because it does not need one.

Ohio Business Central has been the Secretary of State's online filing gateway for several years and handles domestic LLC formation, trade names, and statutory agent updates end to end. Ohio does not require an annual report for LLCs, which removes the annual touchpoint that drives volume elsewhere.

Washington's Corporations and Charities Filing System (CCFS) is the current generation of the state's portal, replacing an older system in the prior years. LLC formation is $200 online. The state requires the current browser versions of Edge or Chrome; Internet Explorer is explicitly unsupported, which is more accessibility-honest than most state systems.

Arizona runs eCorp through the Arizona Corporation Commission, not the Secretary of State; the Commission is the entity-filing authority in Arizona and a handful of other states where the naming convention is different. The $50 online filing has historically carried a routine turnaround measured in weeks, with a $35 expedited option cutting that in roughly half. The Commission has been explicit about its backlog rather than hiding it, which is useful information to have on the front page.

Michigan's LARA Corporations Online Filing System (COFS) handles LLC formation and, as of filings due in 2019, requires annual statements to be submitted online rather than on paper.

The laggards: New York, Alabama, Louisiana, Massachusetts

New York's Department of State, which is a large agency running a very large filing volume, has not yet brought domestic LLC formation into a true web application in mid-2019. The department's e-Statement filing system handles biennial statements ($9 every two years) and a subset of other post-formation filings, but Articles of Organization for a domestic LLC still move through mail, fax, or in-person delivery at One Commerce Plaza in Albany. New York's $200 filing fee is cheap; the Publication Requirement under N.Y. LLC § 206, which demands notice in two newspapers for six consecutive weeks and is frequently the single largest cost of forming in the state, is not. The portal gap compounds this: a would-be New York LLC is paying more to publish than to file, and waiting longer to file than a California or Delaware LLC would wait to both.

Alabama's dual-filing structure is unique among the large states. The Code of Alabama requires that a Certificate of Formation be delivered first to the Judge of Probate in the county of the registered office, recorded locally, and then transmitted to the Secretary of State. The state fee is $100; the probate judge collects a separate fee of at least $50 that varies by county. In June 2019, the Secretary of State's office has extended online filing capability to a small but growing subset of probate counties. Baldwin, Elmore, Jackson, Montgomery, Morgan, and Tuscaloosa are live; a Madison County rollout has been announced under the leadership of Probate Judge Frank Barger and is in transition. The remaining sixty-plus counties still take paper at the probate step, which means a domestic LLC in much of the state begins with a physical trip to the courthouse.

Louisiana's geauxBIZ has been a cautionary tale the state is actively fixing. The portal's initial implementation required users to produce filings through a template the system generated, which left no room for drafting choices common in Louisiana LLC practice and created a documented friction point for practitioners. The 2019 legislative response, Act No. 19 signed by Governor John Bel Edwards on May 29, 2019, authorizes the Secretary of State to "prescribe and furnish" forms and, relevantly for the portal, has been accompanied by a geauxBIZ update that now accepts uploaded PDFs of executed Articles of Organization. The platform was not competitive in early 2019; by the end of the year it should be competent.

Massachusetts's Corporations Division accepts online filing but charges a premium for it: the Certificate of Organization is $500 by mail and $520 online, a $20 convenience fee the state's fee schedule treats as a cost-recovery line item. Annual reports are similarly priced at $500. The portal works; the economics discourage its use for anyone not already paying the annual premium to be in Massachusetts.

What a serious online filing portal actually delivers

After benchmarking fifteen states, three features separate the mature portals from the nominal ones. None of them is glamorous.

The first is an immediate, machine-generated receipt with a filing number. Delaware, Texas, Florida, and California all return a stamped certificate within minutes of the payment confirming. Several laggard states email a human-generated confirmation hours or days later.

The second is a public, accurate status page listing current processing times for the routine and expedited tiers. Delaware publishes its fee schedule with the cutoff times built in. Arizona, candidly, publishes its backlog. Most states publish neither, which means a caller to the Division has to guess or ask.

The third is a browser compatibility statement. Washington's CCFS explicitly supports current Chrome and Edge. This sounds trivial, but the states whose portals silently fail on current browsers make that fact a discovery for every new user rather than a line in the FAQ.

Accessibility, in the formal WCAG sense, is harder to benchmark because most state portals have not published conformance audits. California's bizfile has been the loudest on the topic; the state's Department of Technology requires Section 508 compliance and the bizfile tool was built to clear that bar. Delaware's eCorp predates the current accessibility standards and reflects that lineage. A WCAG 2.1 conformance statement from a state filing office would be a genuinely useful document, and in June 2019 there is not one in circulation.

A rule of thumb for practitioners

If same-day formation matters, use Delaware, Texas, Wyoming, or Colorado and know each state's specific same-day cutoff. If cost dominates and your business is operating where you live, your home-state portal is almost certainly good enough for a standard formation; the exception is New York, where filing by mail and publishing in newspapers for six weeks are genuinely slower and more expensive than they would be in any comparably sized state. If you are in Alabama, call the probate judge before you do anything else, because the county you are registering in decides whether the next hour is a web form or a drive to the courthouse. The portal is not the product; the portal is the schedule. Knowing the schedule is the whole point of this exercise.

For context on the Texas version of this stack specifically, see our earlier walkthrough of what a Texas LLC formation actually costs.

Sources

Keep reading

More from the journal.